Symposia
Child / Adolescent - Anxiety
Rachel A. Schwartz, Ph.D. (she/her/hers)
Psychologist
Rogers Behavioral Health
Philadelphia, PA, United States
Madeline Hartig, MS (she/her/hers)
Research Biostatician
Rogers Behavioral Health
Oconomowoc, WI, United States
Martin E. Franklin, Ph.D.
Executive Director and OCD and Anxiety Service Line Leader
Rogers Behavioral Health
Media, PA, United States
Exposure plus response prevention (ERP) emphasizes fear-reduction strategies, yet many patients have OCD symptoms driven by emotions other than fear. Two prominent forms of Non-Fear-Based (NFB) OCD are: 1) Not Just Right (NJR), when compulsions are performed to achieve inner completeness, and 2) Disgust OCD, in which rituals are done to eliminate feelings of disgust or revulsion. While these presentations respond poorly to standard treatment, ERP might be modified to enhance fit and effectiveness. However, it remains unknown how clinicians tailor ERP to NFB symptoms in practice and to what effect.
Mental health clinicians (N = 97) from diverse backgrounds completed a brief online survey assessing their experiences and perceptions applying ERP with NFB OCD. The survey included a list of 22 (for NJR) and 25 (for disgust) tailoring strategies derived from the empirical literature and authors’ clinical experiences, and asked clinicians to specify which they had used; when a strategy was endorsed, participants rated its helpfulness from 1/Not helpful at all to 4/Very helpful for adults and youth separately. The survey also included open-ended response items assessing other tailoring strategies not mentioned.
Clinicians generally viewed ERP to be somewhat-to-very effective for both NFB presentations. Most strategies surveyed were used commonly and rated as at least “fairly helpful” for both adults and youth. Strategies consistent with inhibitory learning, acceptance and commitment therapy, evaluative conditioning, and cognitive-behavioral interventions traditionally less emphasized in ERP emerged as particularly relevant. Expertise in ERP and NFB OCD was not related to the total number of tailoring strategies endorsed, the endorsement of any given strategy, or ERP’s perceived effectiveness; however, expertise was related to the perceived helpfulness of several strategies. In addition, 13 and 8 novel tailoring strategies for NJR and disgust, respectively, were identified from open-ended response items. Results support the view that ERP can be tailored to treat NFB OCD and inform the development of the first protocol for these difficult-to-treat presentations.